So, I used the same ingredients and mixed and matched until I got the perfect consistency for spreading, sticking, and eating.
- Warm up 1 tsp or less of button until melted.
- Add 1 tsp milk
- Add a dash vanilla (1/4 tsp or so)
- Add 1/2 cup powdered sugar.
- Stir until creamy – then add more powdered sugar, stir, and adjust as needed.
The basic idea is to add a small amount of everything, then add powdered sugar until it ends up the consistency you’re looking for – overshoot a little if you’re not sure. If you want cake frosting, use less powdered sugar overall. But this mix, which ended up having about 1.5 cups of unpacked powdered sugar in it total, was perfect for frosting cookies. It was easy to work with, didn’t harden up too soon, and tastes delicious, even days later.
If you get here in the next ten minutes, you can fight me for the last of this batch! I’ll even throw in a cuppa tea!